World Bank: Falling Short on Rights

Tuesday July 01, 2014 - 23:20:13 in Articles by Super Admin
  • Visits: 3884
  • (Rating 0.0/5 Stars) Total Votes: 0
  • 0 0
  • Share via Social Media

    World Bank: Falling Short on Rights

    World Bank President Jim Kim has taken some steps to advance the bank's respect for human rights but hasn't put in place adequate checks to guard against funding rights abuse, Human Rights Watch said in a report released today on his second

    Share on Twitter Share on facebook Share on Digg Share on Stumbleupon Share on Delicious Share on Google Plus

World Bank President Jim Kim has taken some steps to advance the bank's respect for human rights but hasn't put in place adequate checks to guard against funding rights abuse, Human Rights Watch said in a report released today on his second anniversary as World Bank president.

Since Kim took office as president of the World Bank Group on July 1, 2012, he has tackled discrimination, improved some of the World Bank’s analysis of and response to human rights risks, and taken some steps to learn from the institution’s past mistakes, Human Rights Watch said. In addition to being Kim’s anniversary, July 1, 2014, is the 70th anniversary of the launch of the Bretton Woods conference, at which the creation of the International Monetary Fund and the first arm of the World Bank were negotiated.

"By taking on the scourge of discrimination, President Kim has shown the Work Bank can address human rights issues,” said Jessica Evans, senior advocate on international financial institutions at Human Rights Watch. "The World Bank needs to do more to ensure that its investments improve the human rights climate for the very people it is seeking to help out of poverty.”

Several human rights scandals have blighted Kim’s tenure. Perhaps the most troubling was the World Bank Group’s uncritical support for a project in Honduras that was riven with violence, including killings, Human Rights Watch said. An internal accountability report highlighted how the Bank’s approach to dire human rights risks was woefully deficient.

"World Bank: President Kim’s Two Years on Human Rights,” assesses Kim's reforms, analyzes his missteps, and recommends improvement in three human rights areas central to the World Bank’s goals of eradicating extreme poverty and promoting shared prosperity. Human Rights Watch outlined steps the World Bank should take to help eliminate all forms of discrimination, respect and protect human rights in all the World Bank Group does, and support an environment in which community members and independent groups can freely and effectively hold their governments and international institutions to account.

President Kim has 
criticized draconian anti-gay laws in Uganda, Nigeria, and 81 other countries. Since February, the World Bank has delayed a $90 million loan to Uganda’s health sector to assess how the government’s recently passed anti-gay law might affect the project. This action was necessaryto ensure that the bank did not contribute to marginalization in its project since the law criminalizes "promotion of homosexuality,” directly threatening public health efforts.

But the bank’s efforts to eliminate discrimination are patchy. For instance, even as the World Bank has re-engaged in Burma, it has done little to tackle the horrifying discrimination against the Rohingya, a Muslim minority group, which amounts to ethnic cleansing. Nor has it taken steps to address discrimination on the basis of political and other opinion, including in its own projects, such as in Ethiopia.

The World Bank has done little to counter crackdowns on speech, peaceful assembly, and freedom of association, which are emblematic of the closing space for independent groups, journalists, and activists. The World Bank has an important role to play in fostering an open environment in which people can hold their own governments to account. In several Uzbekistan investments that ran a risk of using forced labor, the World Bank pushed hard for third-party monitoring as a preventive measure, but did nothing to ensure that independent nongovernmental organizations or journalists would be able to monitor whether forced labor was being used within the project areas.

Kim should institutionalize the progress he has made, Human Rights Watch said. The Bank should always ensure that it does not contribute to systemic discrimination on any grounds – sexual orientation and gender identity, as well as gender, ethnicity, religion, language, disability, and political or other opinion among others. It should undertake due diligence to identify and avoid adverse human rights impacts in its projects and programs and ensure that it respects human rights in all that it does. Kim should ensure that the draft new safeguard policies – designed to prevent the World Bank from investing in projects that would harm communities or their environment – make human rights due diligence systematic at the bank.

For the Honduras project, the internal accountability report that highlighted the bank’s failings to assess the human rights situation stemmed from allegations that the International Finance Corporation (IFC), the arm of the bank that lends to private companies, was investing in a company that allegedly conducted, facilitated, or supported forced evictions of farmers in Bajo Aguán, Honduras. The report found that private and public security forces under the company’s control or influence were part of the violent confrontations with peasant groups and were implicated in multiple killings.

The report concluded that IFC staff did not adequately assess and respond to risks of violence and forced evictions in the investment, in violation of the IFC’s own rules. It also found that staff did not undertake adequate due diligence even though there were fatalities and the situation had been brought to their attention. Under much pressure from Kim and the bank’s board, the IFC is now working to remedy the various problems with this investment and reform its procedures, but it has a long way to go, Human Rights Watch said.

While Kim, together with the bank’s board, has emphasized the importance of the World Bank Group learning from its mistakes, it needs to make more meaningful change at the International Finance Corporation (IFC), Human Rights Watch said.

The World Bank Group should:

  • Consistently, both privately and publicly, raise concerns with governments when authorities:
    • Use intimidation, laws, and violence to silence independent groups, arrest journalists and opposition politicians who criticize the government, or introduce repressive laws aimed at silencing civil society;
    • Discriminate against people on any grounds prohibited by international law – race, color, descent or ethnic origin, nationality, language, religion, sex, disability, sexual orientation or gender identity, political or other opinion, national or social origin, property, birth, marital status, HIV status, or other status; or
    • Violate human rights in the name of "development efforts.”
  • Require staff to respect and protect international human rights law and not support any activities that are likely to contribute to or exacerbate human rights abuses and undertake human rights due diligence to identify human rights risks and avoid, address, or mitigate any adverse human rights impact;
  • Articulate time-bound benchmarks for the IFC to demonstrate reform of its institutional culture and incentives, its practices for categorizing environmental and social risk, and its ability to routinely assess and address human rights risks in its investments;
  • Create incentive structures to reward staff for advancing inclusive, sustainable development that spurs positive human rights impact for marginalized communities, in close compliance with safeguard policies/performance standards, and sanctions when harm occurs due to staff negligence; and
  • Through its Doing Business Report, measure the degree to which governments require businesses under their jurisdiction to carry out robust and transparent human rights due diligence; and publicly report on their human rights, social, and environmental impacts, as well as payments made to domestic or foreign governments.

"The World Bank has taken steps in certain cases to identify human rights problems and worked to address them,” Evans said. "Now is the time for it to make this effort systematic and recognize that universal human rights are not discretionary.”

"World Bank: Human Rights Status Report and Action Plan” is available at:

"A Human Rights Agenda for the World Bank’s New President” is available at:

"Abuse-Free Development: How the World Bank Should Safeguard Against Human Rights Violations” is available at:

For more Human Rights Watch reporting on the World Bank, please visit:

For more information, please contact:
In Washington, DC, Jessica Evans (English): +1-917-930-7763 (mobile); or [email protected]. Follow on Twitter @evans_jessica

Share on Social Media

Djibouti:Protect Jailed Air Force Pilot's Rights

Allow Peaceful Protests, Protect Media Freedom Djibouti's authorities should impartially investigate alleged mistreatment of a detained former air force pilot and ensure that his due process rights are respected, Human Rights Watch said today. The authorities have repressed peaceful protests that broke out in response to the pilot's detention. Full Article


Belgium has rejected the asylum request of a woman who is a human rights and young girls' activist in Mogadishu.

Government of Belgium has rejected the asylum request of a woman who is a human rights and young girls' activist in Mogadishu. Full Article


Abdi Iley Apologises To The People Of Ethiopia's Somali Region Over Rights Abuses

Abdi Iley Apologises To The People Of Ethiopia's Somali Region Over Rights Abuses Full Article


Somali Identification Team Meets With World Bank Officials To Boost ID Efforts In Somalia

Somali Identification Team Meets With World Bank Officials To Boost ID Efforts In Somalia Full Article


Child Rights Training for Journalists concluded in Mogadishu

The National Union of Somali Journalists supported by UNICEF have successfully concluded a three day training on child rights in Mogadishu on Monday. Full Article


World's 8 Richest People Mostly Progressive, Own More $$ than Half the World Population

The world's eight richest people own as much as half the world's population, according to an analysis by the charity Oxfam. Full Article


[Topnews:-] Akhri Human rights oo faafisay tacadiyadda Damujadiid iyo NISA kula kaceen shacabka Soomaaliyeed ?

Dadka rayidka ah ee Soomaaliya oo u adkeysanayay tacaddiyada ay kala kulmayeen dhammaan dhinacyada ku lugta leh dagaalka, ayna taa u dheertahay xaalad adag oo bani'aadannimo, ayaa weli waxa ay dhibaato kala kulmayaan colaadda muddada ka socotay dalkaasi. Ballanqaadkii dowladda ee ahaa in ay wanaajineyso ammaanka deegaannada ay maamusho, isla markaana ay dhiseyso tayada hay'adaha sharciga, ayaanay waxbadan ka hirgelin sanadkii 2016-ka. Full Article


[Daawo] Human Rights oo olole ugu jirta in Maxkamad la taago dimbiile Cabdi ileey

Daawo Human Rights oo olole ugu jirta in Maxkamad la taago dimbiile Cabdi ileey iyo banaanbaxayaashii Australia oo eheladooda Jigjiga lagu goowracay Full Article


Finland's newest asylum seeker is culprit of serious human rights crimes

Men accused of human rights abuses in Somalia have laid their own claims to the Scandinavian dream and now try to enjoy the same freedoms they're accused of trying to take away from their own compatriots. Full Article


Germany: Merkel Should Press Rights on Africa Trip

Curbing Security Force Abuses, Ensuring Justice Crucial in Ethiopia, Mali Full Article


Leave a comment






Somalia:War to Defeat Al Shabab Militarily

President HSM's Proclamation to Defeat Al-Shabab by Force in Somalia To overcome the complex problems of civil war, state fragility, and underdevelopment, the Somali people supported risky political changes for a government that promotes freedom, justice, peace, and prosperity in Somalia. For example, the Islamic movements enjoyed popular support to end the brutal reigns of warlords and the military occupation of Ethiopia and establish new government.

Somalia:$17 million external support has not been channeled through the country's single treasury account

Waagacusub.net -Auditor General Mohamed Ali alias Afgoi has exposed missing millions of dollars from key departments within the Federal Government of Somalia [FGS], in what could raise questions about government expenditures. In his report, Afgoi said 25 entities and three embassies have been audited. Unsupported expenditure amounts to $9M; contracts worth $31M not registered with auditor general's office, the existence of unauthorized bank accounts outside the Treasury Single Account.

Al-qaida Share ,IBS bank Somalia launches Visa Card Payment

Waagacusub.net - IBS Bank Somalia, which is believed to have the largest amount of money, Al-Qaeda Finance Secretary Fazul Abdallah from Comoros has started issuing Visa Card Payments for the first time. Al-Shabaab's finance secretary confirmed that Mohamed Ali Warsame had $ 157 million in cash, according to Khalif Ereg, who was later bribed with $ 2 million.

UGANDA: New Cabinet Members and Ministers of State

I hereby inform the country that By virtue of the Authority given to the President of Uganda by Articles: 108(2), 108A(1), 113(1) and 114(1) of the 1995 Constitution of the Republic of Uganda, I hereby appoint H.E. the Vice President, Rt. Hon. Prime Minister, Honourable Cabinet Ministers and other Ministers as indicated below:

Journalists barred from covering Somali leaders' meeting

The Associated Somali Journalists is deeply concerned that journalists were today barred from covering the meeting of the leaders of the Federal Government of Somalia and Federal Member States (FMSs) as well as the Governor and Mayor of Mogadishu.

President Mahad Salaad: the Only Guarantor for Galmudug's Security and Prosperity

Galmudug State is not just the geographic heart of Somalia but the quintessential soul of the Somali nation. Within Galmudug, all the major Somali clan lineages- the Hawiye, Dir, Darood and Madhibaan are represented. No other Somali region or state is home to such diverse and influential clans with such extensive historical significance in Somalia as found in the Galmudug territory. Economically, Galmudug in 2024 is set to be the first location for the offshore oil and gas that the Somali Federal Government in partnership with the Houston-based American company, Coastline Exploration have commenced work on off the Hobyo coast since 2021. Full Article


Somalia's leader mourns death of Namibia president

Waagacusub.net - Somalia's President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud on Sunday mourned the death of Namibia President Hage G. Geingob and sent condolences to the government of the African country. Full Article


Somalia's ex-president warns of risk of 'political crisis' over plans to overhaul constitution

Waagacusub.net - Somalia's former President Mohamed Abdullahi Farmajo on Monday warned of the risk of political crisis over plans by the incumbent President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud to overhaul the constitution. Full Article


Egyptian President says will protect Somalia against anz threat

Waagacusub.net - Egyptian President Abdel Fattah el-Sissi said his country will protect Somalia against any threat in what can be described as an indirect response to recent Ethiopia's move to access the seaport of Somaliland. Full Article


Egypt Condemns Suicide Bomber Attack in Somalia

Egypt on Tuesday condemned a suicide bomber attack in Somalia that killed at least 20 soldiers. The attack took place at a training camp in the Somali capital, Mogadishu, on Monday. The al-Shabab terrorist group claimed responsibility. Full Article


Hormuud telecom and Al-Shabaab's Strategy of Destroying Mobile Communication Masts

Hormuud's Assault on African Peacekeepers Figure 14: African Peace Keepers Hormuud launched a scorching public campaign against the Kenyan military forces in AMISOM in late August 2019. Full Article


Former Intel official stripped from NISA membership

Former Intel official stripped from NISA membership Full Article





Abiy says 'New Year' will be celebrated in Eritrea, Ethiopian Airlines to resume flights

Abiy says 'New Year' will be celebrated in Eritrea, Ethiopian Airlines to resume flights Full Article


Massive rise in Islamist militant attacks in Africa

Massive rise in Islamist militant attacks in Africa Full Article