HEADLINES:

Somalia violated domestic and international law in extraditing Qalbi Dhagah

0
Sunday September 10, 2017 - 00:37:23 in Articles by Super Admin
  • Visits: 7642
  • (Rating 5.0/5 Stars) Total Votes: 6
  • 6 0
  • Share via Social Media

    Somalia violated domestic and international law in extraditing Qalbi Dhagah

    Waagacusub.net - The government grossly violated the Constitution and International Laws in handing over ONLF senior leader Qalbi Dhagah to Ethiopia, an international legal expert has said noting the government failed to study the relevant laws befor

    Share on Twitter Share on facebook Share on Digg Share on Stumbleupon Share on Delicious Share on Google Plus

Waagacusub.net - The government grossly violated the Constitution and International Laws in handing over ONLF senior leader Qalbi Dhagah to Ethiopia, an international legal expert has said noting the government failed to study the relevant laws before acceding to Ethiopia's request to surrender the embattled leader.

Somalia’s Provisional Constitution, UN Conventions and the regional bloc IGAD Convention on Extradition expressly sanctioned against such a move, the legal expert who requested not to be named for security reasons told Goobjoog News.

"Articles 4, 8, 35, 36 and 37 of the Provisional Constitution provides guidelines on dealing with a case as that of Qalbi Dhagah. Similarly, the UN Convention on Convention Against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment and the IGAD Convention on Extradition must be looked at clearly before a state party responds to an extradition request,” the source said.

Due process

Article 36, for instance, prescribes the manner in which the state can follow in matters relating to extradition. "Any person who has been accused or convicted may be extradited only in a manner prescribed by law and on the basis of an international treaty or convention which the Federal Republic of Somalia is party to, and which obliges the Federal State of Somalia to extradite the accused or convicted.”

Any accused or convicted person, Article 36 (b) reads, shall be extradited only in accordance with international law and practice, and on the basis of legislation governing extradition, which has been passed by the Federal Parliament.

The legal expert poked holes on the government’s reasoning relying on two agreements signed between Somalia and the Somali state in Ethiopia (Ogaden). "We need to establish the legal standing of these agreements. The question to pose would be, were they sanctioned at the state level between the two countries?

Legal merit

It appears from reading this documents, the legal expert said these were agreements between regions of both countries. Did Mahad Salad (then State Minister in the office of the president who signed the June 7, 2015, agreements) append his signature with the blessings of the state?

It follows therefore that the documents may not be interpreted as constituting a legally binding agreement by two countries recognized by international law, the expert said.

Both Mahad Salad and former Galmudug State President, both who signed the documents have dismissed the government’s argument noting the agreements were meant to address conflicts between regions in Somalia and Ethiopia and did not in any way constitute bilateral agreements between Somalia and Ethiopia.

Torture

Article 3 of the UN Convention Against Torture notes that state parties shall not extradite persons to another state where there are substantial grounds for believing that he would be in danger of being subjected to torture. The second part of this article calls on state parties to take into account all relevant considerations including, where applicable, the existence in the State concerned of a consistent pattern of gross, flagrant or mass violations of human rights. Human rights organizations including Human Rights Watch have pointed out several cases of human rights violations in Ethiopia including torture, detention without trial and use of state machinery to suppress dissent.

Ethiopia passed a controversial anti-terrorism law in 2009.

Exhaust domestic legal options

The legal expert further observes Somalia, as prescribed by international law could have sought to exhaust all the existing legal channels before handing over Qalbi Dhagah including trying him in Somali law courts for the crimes he is accused of. Even for terrorists, the expert notes legal recourse in the requested country (Somalia) must be taken into consideration particularly in instances where there is ground that the suspect could face torture in the requesting country (Ethiopia).

Citing the case of the radical Islamic cleric Abu Qatada in the UK and Jordan, the legal expert observed the UK was compelled under international law to ensure the cleric would not be tried based on evidence procured under duress. In the case, there was information that evidence secured by state agents through the torture of suspects was to be used against Abu Qatada during his trial in Jordan but the UK had to seek assurances from the Jordanian government that it did not intend to adduce the evidence against the cleric before it allowed he be handed over.

Abu Qatada was later (September 2014) exonerated of any wrong doings for his alleged involvement in a plot to bomb Christian sites in Jordan and other targets in 2000. Subsequently, the court also cleared him of involvement in a 1998 bomb plot.

Parliament will be expected to debate the Qalbi Dhagah case today as it resumes seating.

Share on Social Media

Somalia:Social media shut down over exam leakages unjustified

Responding to reports that Somalia's education minister has announced that social media may be shut down for five days from 27 to 31 May as one of the ways to stop cheating in the national secondary school exams, Amnesty International's Deputy Regional Director for East Africa, the Horn and the Great Lakes Seif Magango said: Full Article

 

Somalia:Mogadishu has fallen back into the hands of terrorists

Waagacusub.com - Huge explosions have rocket the Somali capital. They became incontrollable, as they occur at least twice, while targeting government officials and their offices. Al Shabab terrorists seem to be recapturing the control of Mogadishu after the government troops and police vacated their bases in the front lines in lower and middle Shabelle regions. Full Article

 

Leadership Crisis Caused Freeze of Statebuilding Efforts in Somalia

Waagacusub.net - Somalia is mired in out of control political and security situation created by broken electoral promises, egregious abuses, and foreign policy blunders committed by the federal government of President Mohamed Abdullahi Farmajo. The Gulf crisis, the moratorium of the Federal Member States (FMS), and the surrender to the manipulations of divide and rule of Ethiopia have elevated public pessimism and stoked intense acrimony between federal and state leaders, which have exacerbated Somalia's vulnerability and relapse into chaos. Federal Government could soon be isolated for directionless. Full Article

 

Somalia marks 1 year since devastating Mogadishu bombing

Somalia marks 1 year since devastating Mogadishu bombing Full Article

 

Somalia: Two people hurt in bomb attack in Baidoa

Somalia: Two people hurt in bomb attack in Baidoa Full Article

 

US military denies conducting airstrike in Somalia

US military denies conducting airstrike in Somalia Full Article

 

Somalia leaders urged to stop regional affairs interference

Somalia leaders urged to stop regional affairs interference Full Article

 

African Union to secure gains made in Somalia

African Union to secure gains made in Somalia Full Article

 

Somalia: Roadside blast hits AU troops in Janaale town

Somalia: Roadside blast hits AU troops in Janaale town Full Article

 

Ethiopia, Somalia urge dialogue to resolve Eritrea, Djibouti dispute

Ethiopia, Somalia urge dialogue to resolve Eritrea, Djibouti dispute Full Article

 


Leave a comment

  Tip

  Tip

  Tip

  Tip

  Tip


Somali Officials Misrepresent IMF Statements and Reports

Somalia suffers from the disgraceful culture of leaders and politicians invoking deceptively legitimate documents like the Provisional Constitution for bolstering false claims and arguments or for obfuscating critical search for truth. That culture has undermined the requirement of truth, good faith, and accountability in the public life and dashed the public hope for democratic state of Somalia governed by the rule of law and democratic values.

Somalia:Terrorists receive 52 million dollars in Mogadishu annually.

Waagacusub.net - It has been known that Al-Shabab receives 52 Million dollars annually from Mogadishu. It gets from commercial companies, and public as taxes (zakawat)

Chinese oil companies behind unlawful "extradition" of a Somali to Ethiopia

Waagacusub.net - A Chinese oil company was involved in the smuggling of a former Somali rebel officer, Colonel Abdikariim Sheikh Muse, to Ethiopia because his organization of the Ogaden National Liberation Front (ONLF) was against oil and mineral exploration in Ogaden of the southeastern Ethiopia by China.

Journalist Alasow "Somalische Minister houdt Amsterdamse rechter vals bewijs Voor"

Volgens de rechter zou de minister hebben aangetoond dat afpersingspraktijken van Somalische journalisten een bekend probleem zijn en stelde de bewindsman daarmee een ernstige misstand aan de kaak. Dat is een kwestie van algemeen belang en de minister moet daarover in de openbaarheid kunnen treden, overwoog de rechter.

Somalia:List Document retrieved from house of AlShabaab leader

Waagacusub.net– An American unmanned drone launched a missile attack on one of Alshabab's most cold-blooded leaders on Sunday, 30 July 2017 in southern Somalia. The drove attack killed a man, who is dubbed the cruelest terror mastermind in the Mogadishu's history.

Somalia:Social media shut down over exam leakages unjustified

Responding to reports that Somalia's education minister has announced that social media may be shut down for five days from 27 to 31 May as one of the ways to stop cheating in the national secondary school exams, Amnesty International's Deputy Regional Director for East Africa, the Horn and the Great Lakes Seif Magango said: Full Article

 

UNDP sanctions 18 Somali entities and individuals over graft, collusion and fraud

The UN Development Programme has blacklisted 18 Somali individuals and organisations from conducting any business with the UN agency over what it termed as their 'engagement in proscribed practices'. Full Article

 

Somalia:Mogadishu has fallen back into the hands of terrorists

Waagacusub.com - Huge explosions have rocket the Somali capital. They became incontrollable, as they occur at least twice, while targeting government officials and their offices. Al Shabab terrorists seem to be recapturing the control of Mogadishu after the government troops and police vacated their bases in the front lines in lower and middle Shabelle regions. Full Article

 

CORRECTION: Mr ABDIRAHMAN OMAR OSMAN

In multiple publications on this website I have deliberately associated Mr. Abdirahman Omar Osman with rape, impregnating of a Somali girl, murder and violence and fraud. Full Article

 

Somali Officials Misrepresent IMF Statements and Reports

Somalia suffers from the disgraceful culture of leaders and politicians invoking deceptively legitimate documents like the Provisional Constitution for bolstering false claims and arguments or for obfuscating critical search for truth. That culture has undermined the requirement of truth, good faith, and accountability in the public life and dashed the public hope for democratic state of Somalia governed by the rule of law and democratic values. Full Article

 

Former Intel official stripped from NISA membership

Former Intel official stripped from NISA membership Full Article

 

PM KHEYRE USELESS AND COSTY OVERSEAS TRIPS.

PM KHEYRE USELESS AND COSTY OVERSEAS TRIPS. Full Article

 

Abiy says 'New Year' will be celebrated in Eritrea, Ethiopian Airlines to resume flights

Abiy says 'New Year' will be celebrated in Eritrea, Ethiopian Airlines to resume flights Full Article

 

Massive rise in Islamist militant attacks in Africa

Massive rise in Islamist militant attacks in Africa Full Article

 

Argentina Cancels Israel Match After Messi Protests Over Palestinian Killings

Argentina Cancels Israel Match After Messi Protests Over Palestinian Killings Full Article