Nato's painful homecoming

Thursday June 07, 2018 - 20:43:47 in Daily News by Journalist Bashiir
  • Visits: 318
  • (Rating 2.0/5 Stars) Total Votes: 2
  • 0 0
  • Share via Social Media

    Nato's painful homecoming

    Nato's painful homecoming

    Share on Twitter Share on facebook Share on Digg Share on Stumbleupon Share on Delicious Share on Google Plus

Nato's painful homecoming

Past civilisations erected great monuments to show their power and influence, and in a sense Nato's brand new glass and steel headquarters building in Brussels is similarly intended to send a signal of the alliance's potency and relevance as tensions with a resurgent Russia once again dominate its agenda.

The building's sweeping lines - it looks like several giant launch-ramps or ski-jumps fused together - sends out a clinical message of modernity and efficiency. 

It could be a high-tech company's global hub; the only difference being those parts of the building that probably extend underground. Nato is giving no tours there!

It stands in stark contrast to the old headquarters just across the road - a drab, low-rise building, that was a former Belgian military hospital. 

It has been the alliance's headquarters since it was forced to move from Paris in the mid-1960s. 

However, as the alliance expanded it became ever more crowded; patently unsuited to the job of hosting the 21st Century world's premier military and diplomatic alliance.

Mounting tensions

As Nato defence ministers gather here for their first meeting in the new building - the last ministerial before a crucial summit in early July, the main message the image-makers will want us to take away will be of a business-like organisation in its new business-like home.

But everything in the Nato garden is far from rosy. 

With just weeks to go before the summit and President Donald Trump's second visit to the alliance, tensions are mounting.

Europe and the US stand on the edge of an unpleasant trade war prompted by the Trump administration's decision to pull out of the nuclear deal with Iran and to threaten sanctions against any European companies who still hope to trade with Tehran. 

Trans-Atlantic divisions over Iran are not the only problem.

The US is said to be closer to imposing separate sanctions against German and other European energy companies in an effort to prevent construction of a pipeline to carry Russian gas across the Baltic. 

The US decision to move its embassy in Israel from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem caused deep unease in many European capitals. Undiplomatic comments from the US ambassador to Germany talking about his desire to boost right-wing parties throughout Europe caused annoyance in Berlin and beyond. 

President Trump looks less like the uncrowned leader of the Western alliance and more like a divider - his "America first" policy leaving little room for the sort of compromises that are essential to a healthy alliance with a collective sense of purpose. 

And of course nobody knows which Donald Trump will turn up at the summit. 

Will it be a benevolent leader championing US commitment to the defence of Europe while urging the Europeans politely to spend more on their military budgets? 

Or will it be the Donald Trump who visited the old Nato headquarters in May of last year - a president who was blunt, appeared singularly ill-informed about Nato's budgetary processes and founding treaty and whose speech was met with barely-hidden sniggering from some key European leaders?

The Russian factor

If you then consider the tensions between the US and key Nato ally Turkey, which has recently been pursuing a partial tilt towards Moscow. 

Now mix in the implications of the new government in Rome, which again has some curious attitudes towards Russia. 

Then add the worrying schism within Europe between the "traditional" liberal democracies of the West and the increasingly harsh tones of "the populist democracies" of the East and you get a picture of an alliance riven with tensions.

Image captionPresident Vladimir Putin has warned the West not to cross "red lines", referring to Russia's national security interests

This is before one even begins to talk about Nato's core business - the collective defence of its members. 

Some certainly overstate the nature of Russia's military threat to the West, but a threat of some kind is real enough. 

Indeed, it may be less from Russian tank armies as of old and more to do with cyber-influence, information operations and propaganda war. 

But it is a battle that has already been joined and - despite President Vladimir Putin's recent benevolent sounding statements directed at the EU - many will choose to judge Russia by its actions rather than its words.

Nonetheless, the precise nature of this Russian challenge and what Nato collectively must do to meet it also divides the alliance. 

Countries like Poland and the Baltic Republics, with a very different historical relationship with Moscow, see a much more immediate threat than other Nato allies. 

A trial balloon from the Polish ministry of defence asking for the deployment of a permanently-based US division on Polish soil seems to fly in the face of existing Nato policy and suggests that some at least in Warsaw are not convinced that the alliance's current approach is sufficient.

Those allies bordering the Mediterranean in Nato's south worry about Russia, But their biggest security threat remains the influx of people and instability from the Middle East and Africa - population movements which are becoming a key driver of political developments in a number of Nato countries. 

The 'four 30s' plan

Either way, the summit will focus a good deal on "strength in depth", which makes a catchy slogan, but what does it really mean? 

There's talk of Nato leaders agreeing to a new formula - "the four 30s" - a plan to be able to muster 30 mechanised battalions, 30 air force squadrons and 30 major warships within 30 days of the outbreak of any crisis. 

But is this timeline really serious? Might it be too slow? 

And given the lamentable readiness of Germany's armed forces for example, on paper one of the strongest countries in the Alliance, are such goals attainable or simply an aspiration? 

Much also needs to be done to improve Nato's logistical support structure. For example, a key petroleum pipeline only extends as far as the old Cold War border between East and West Germany at the Fulda Gap.

Governments manage to employ a peculiar schizophrenia in the international system. Some might call it compartmentalisation. They agree in one forum whilst being at daggers drawn in another. 

You will hear all sorts of statements that Nato is in rude health and busily adapting to the new challenges it faces. 

In part this is true - at least in terms of the professional military and civil service. But no amount of spin can cover up the wider and multiple crises in the Nato family. 

Pouring some balm on these tensions is what you would expect from a "normal" Nato summit and a "normal" US administration. 

Is Mr Trump up to the task? 

We will find out in a little over a month's time.

Share on Social Media
No Related Items Found

Leave a comment






Somalia:Terrorists receive 52 million dollars in Mogadishu annually.

Waagacusub.net - It has been known that Al-Shabab receives 52 Million dollars annually from Mogadishu. It gets from commercial companies, and public as taxes (zakawat)

Chinese oil companies behind unlawful "extradition" of a Somali to Ethiopia

Waagacusub.net - A Chinese oil company was involved in the smuggling of a former Somali rebel officer, Colonel Abdikariim Sheikh Muse, to Ethiopia because his organization of the Ogaden National Liberation Front (ONLF) was against oil and mineral exploration in Ogaden of the southeastern Ethiopia by China.

Journalist Alasow "Somalische Minister houdt Amsterdamse rechter vals bewijs Voor"

Volgens de rechter zou de minister hebben aangetoond dat afpersingspraktijken van Somalische journalisten een bekend probleem zijn en stelde de bewindsman daarmee een ernstige misstand aan de kaak. Dat is een kwestie van algemeen belang en de minister moet daarover in de openbaarheid kunnen treden, overwoog de rechter.

Somalia:List Document retrieved from house of AlShabaab leader

Waagacusub.net– An American unmanned drone launched a missile attack on one of Alshabab's most cold-blooded leaders on Sunday, 30 July 2017 in southern Somalia. The drove attack killed a man, who is dubbed the cruelest terror mastermind in the Mogadishu's history.

Somali President true scandal "violation of law"

Waagacusub.net - The presidency of Somalia's Mohamed Abdullahi Farmaajo is only eight months old but already his administration faces its first crisis - and it is one of their own making.

Leadership Crisis Caused Freeze of Statebuilding Efforts in Somalia

Waagacusub.net - Somalia is mired in out of control political and security situation created by broken electoral promises, egregious abuses, and foreign policy blunders committed by the federal government of President Mohamed Abdullahi Farmajo. The Gulf crisis, the moratorium of the Federal Member States (FMS), and the surrender to the manipulations of divide and rule of Ethiopia have elevated public pessimism and stoked intense acrimony between federal and state leaders, which have exacerbated Somalia's vulnerability and relapse into chaos. Federal Government could soon be isolated for directionless. Full Article


Top Secret: Ethiopia discovered President Mustafa Agjar and his cabinet belong to one religious party

Ethiopian intelligence officials discovered that President Agjar and all the ministers he appointed belong to the religious group Al-Islah Al-Itihad. This became a surprise to them, according to an official who spoke to Waagacusub.com Full Article


27 Shocking And Unbelievable Trump Quotes About Women

Have you ever had to be in a congress where Donald Trump said disparaging things about women or have you ever had to sit to watch the TV to hear the great American President speak but you end up leaving in disappointment because all you hear in-between words are anti-feminist statements? Full Article



Waagacusub.net - Several members of Prime Minister Hassan Ali Kheyre's cabinet and senior government officials including close associates have been linked to money laundering, graft and corruption, according to sources. Some officials have allegedly been extorting businesses and NGO's, receiving illegal kickbacks, and steering inflated contracts to politicians, friends and family members as part of corrupt scheme. While other officials have misused development funds for regions, laundering millions of dollars to private bank accounts in Nairobi, Doha, London and Toronto. Full Article


Belgium has rejected the asylum request of a woman who is a human rights and young girls' activist in Mogadishu.

Government of Belgium has rejected the asylum request of a woman who is a human rights and young girls' activist in Mogadishu. Full Article


Former Intel official stripped from NISA membership

Former Intel official stripped from NISA membership Full Article





Abiy says 'New Year' will be celebrated in Eritrea, Ethiopian Airlines to resume flights

Abiy says 'New Year' will be celebrated in Eritrea, Ethiopian Airlines to resume flights Full Article


Massive rise in Islamist militant attacks in Africa

Massive rise in Islamist militant attacks in Africa Full Article


Argentina Cancels Israel Match After Messi Protests Over Palestinian Killings

Argentina Cancels Israel Match After Messi Protests Over Palestinian Killings Full Article